US university students tell surveillance cameras to Flock off theguardian.com · ...
HN Best 200 @best
US university students tell surveillance cameras to Flock off theguardian.com · 45 points · 9 comments · HN thread
TL;DR A Guardian feature reports that at least ten US university campuses across seven states have dropped Flock Safety license plate reader contracts since April 2026, while student activists push further against any automated plate-reader surveillance. Some schools swapped to other vendors such as Genetec and Axon, and high school students have started similar petitions.
- At least ten universities in seven states, including Cornell, Penn State, Emory, Binghamton, Kent State and several University of Wisconsin branches, have scrapped Flock contracts since April.
- Stanford cut ties with Flock this summer and is installing Genetec ALPRs, which Genetec will store on internal servers for 30 days; Binghamton switched to Axon.
- Replacing Flock with other vendors is the most common outcome, and student organizers are now demanding no ALPR contract at all.
- Elgin Community College could not cancel its contract early and covered the cameras with trash bags until the agreement lapsed in April.
- UNC Charlotte restricted national access to its Flock records after WBTV found Houston police had searched its network 183,000 times between March and May 2026.
- Flock says its cameras help solve crimes and denies mass surveillance and federal immigration partnerships, though news reports document indirect local police help to ICE.
- High school students in Colorado and Georgia have also launched petitions against Flock cameras on or near their campuses.
Discussion The comment thread is small, with a handful of comments that mostly focus on how Flock's access controls work and whether local opposition can succeed. The mood is skeptical and pragmatic rather than outraged: commenters question whether 'national access' restrictions default to allow-all, debate whether cross-jurisdiction searches are a valid reason for broad access, and discuss how to influence local officials, including through school board elections. A few commenters push back on the framing that the surveillance is illegal at all.
- Access restrictions are weak if they are opt-in (some): Commenters question whether the 'restricted national access' setting is a real safeguard, noting that it is opt-in and that most departments using Flock have chosen it. The concern is that the default still allows broad sharing.
- Broad access is needed to catch fleeing suspects (a few): One commenter argues that criminals travel across jurisdictions and police cast wide nets to find them, which justifies national access to plate reader data.
- Local officials can be pressured through elections (a few): A commenter suggests that school board races are often decided by small numbers of votes, so campaigning for candidates with strong anti-surveillance positions is a more effective route than petitions alone.
- Supporting local surveillance while accepting vendor swaps (a few): One commenter says they back their local San Francisco supervisor's support for the cameras and would accept switching to Axon or a lesser-known brand if Flock becomes politically impossible.
- Legal fight belongs in Congress, not courts (a few): One commenter asks about taking Flock to the Supreme Court, but another replies that Flock's practices are not clearly illegal and that the issue belongs in Congress.
Links from the comments
#surveillance #licensePlateReaders #flockSafety #universities #privacy #activism